There's a specific kind of disappointment that comes from trying period underwear for the first time and realising it's just not for you.

Not because the idea is bad. The idea is great. Reusable, no applicators, no wings sticking to everything, no 3am pad emergency. The concept makes complete sense. It's the execution that gets you.

Because if you have hips — real hips, thighs that touch, a body that curves — most period underwear fits you like an afterthought. The leg elastic digs in exactly where your thighs are widest. By day two there's a mark. By day three there's a rash. And you spend five days hyper-aware of something that was supposed to make your life easier.

So you go back to pads. And you tell yourself period underwear just isn't for you.

Here's the thing though. It might not be the period underwear concept that failed you. It might just be the cut.

Most period underwear is built with tight elastic around the leg opening. That elastic is doing a job — it's trying to keep everything in place and prevent leaks at the edges. But on a pear shaped body, tight elastic at the widest point of your thigh isn't comfortable. It's a tourniquet.

The fix isn't complicated. It's a longer leg length and a soft waistband that doesn't rely on elastic to do its job. When the fabric itself does the smoothing — when there's no rigid elastic cutting across your hip line — the whole experience changes. It stops feeling like a product you're tolerating and starts feeling like underwear you'd actually reach for.

Which, when you think about it, is the entire point.

Nobody should spend five days a month in something uncomfortable just to manage something that's already uncomfortable. Your period is enough. Your underwear should be the least of it.

The best version of period underwear feels like your favourite everyday pair. Soft waistband. Breathable fabric. Nothing digging, nothing marking, nothing you're counting down to taking off.

If you've tried period underwear and written it off — it might be worth trying it in a cut that was actually designed for your body.

April 05, 2026 — Jody-anne Sellwood

Leave a comment